What Job Did Scrooge Have

Many companies featured on Money advertise with u.s.a.. Opinions are our own, but compensation and
in-depth research determine where and how companies may appear. Learn more about how we make money.

Everyday Money
loans
How Ebenezer Scrooge Got Rebranded as a Capitalist Hero

How Ebenezer Scrooge Got Rebranded every bit a Capitalist Hero

The word Scrooge has get shorthand for a practitioner of cruel, greedy, miserly corporatism. But was Ebenezer really so bad?

Maybe not. Over the last few years, Charles Dickens'south cold-hearted villain has been warmly embraced by some costless-market purists, who hold upwards the old miser equally an emblem of shrewd, clear-eyed business savvy. It's good timing, also: Scrooge looks downright honorable when compared to the disgraced corporate executives and politicians of 2016, the blazon engage in sketchy backroom deals and overcharging schemes.

At least Ebenezer is upfront about it, the argument goes.

As he appears in the original Dickens, Scrooge is a self-made small business concern owner. He is undeniably a buzzkill around the holidays. But he as well comes beyond as an altogether adept businessman—an honest, responsible moneylender, somebody who'd give y'all a fair deal on a mortgage. His sins essentially consist of lacking generosity. He may be a stingy, miserable one-time creepo, merely he's not a Christmas criminal in the league of the Grinch or the thieves in Home Lone. He doesn't engage in unethical business practices either, like the way Mr. Potter hides Bailey Edifice and Loan's lost money in It'due south a Wonderful Life. There's never a whiff in A Christmas Carol of Scrooge doing anything deceptive or quack.

In fact, you could see Scrooge equally a colonnade of the community, a human whose moneylending helped people bankroll homes and businesses. By extension, the argument goes, Scrooge and his ilk were partly responsible for the Industrial Revolution, which additional local and global wealth.

Individuals like Scrooge were "critical to the cosmos of a wealthier England—and a wealthier, fairer world," Competitive Enterprise Institute founder Fred Smith wrote in a Forbes column referring to Scrooge every bit the "Ultimate Job Creator." (The Institute is dedicated to "advancing the principles of limited regime, free enterprise, and individual liberty.")

"The biggest of the Big Lies about Scrooge is the pointlessness of his pursuit of coin," Michael Levin, a philosophy professor at City University of New York, argued in an essay defending the character. "To discover the good he does 1 need only enquire of the borrowers. Here is a homeowner with a new roof, and there a merchant able to finance a shipment of tea, bringing profit to himself and happiness to tea drinkers, all thanks to Scrooge."

Perhaps Scrooge has been getting a bad rap. He is considered cruel and selfish for chastising his employee, Bob Cratchit, for burning too much coal at piece of work. But another way to categorize his behavior is that of old-fashioned thrift. It's not similar Cratchit froze while Scrooge was sitting in his skivvies in the side by side room hoarding the heat. Scrooge subjected himself to the aforementioned atmospheric condition, conserving energy (and money) at home and the office alike. Barely a candle burned in his house, Dickens writes, considering "darkness was cheap, and Scrooge liked it." The idea of enriching himself to enjoy the kind of lavish decadence portrayed in The Wolf of Wall Street would be unimaginable to Scrooge.

And if Bob Cratchit were better at his chore, Levin argues, Scrooge would pay him more: "No doubt Cratchit needs—i.e., wants—more, to support his family and care for Tiny Tim. But Scrooge did not forcefulness Cratchit to father children he is having difficulty supporting," he writes.

Speaking of Cratchit, he's the but character in the book to voice genuine appreciation for Scrooge. Cratchit offers a toast over Christmas dinner to his boss, acknowledging that Scrooge is responsible for his livelihood and raising a glass to "the Founder of the Feast!"

The remainder of the large Cratchit clan routinely refers to Scrooge as an "Ogre." Mrs. Cratchit even calls him "an odious, stingy, hard, unfeeling man." Yet Bob Cratchit is "a fellow member of the British centre class," David John Marotta, of the Marotta Wealth Direction firm, notes in 1 of his frequent ruminations on A Christmas Carol. "He lives a genteel life. He goes to work with a coat and tie on. His family lives in a four-room house and has a much easier working existence than most of Victorian England. Bob Cratchit earns more than than an ample wage."

Then in that location's Tiny Tim, the Cratchit's crippled son. Presumably, Tim's health could take been improved if the Cratchits had more than money, by way of a fat raise from Scrooge. But does this theory hold upwardly given the reality at the fourth dimension of the story? "The medicine bachelor in the 1830s was mostly useless or worse," the Chicago Tribune reported. "Information technology is ludicrous to suggest that with coin from Scrooge the Cratchits would have been able to buy Tim a cure for multiple sclerosis or whatever it was he suffered from." Today's insurers won't pay a dime for unproven medical care. Should we hold a small business possessor in early 19th century England to a higher?

Marotta even blamed Bob Cratchit's spendthrift means as a reason for his brood's suffering, noting that the money spent on their Christmas goose solitary could accept covered "a year'due south supply of medical attention for the entire family."

While Scrooge isn't a nice guy, he can't exist defendant of being a hypocrite or a thief. His supposedly benevolent nephew Fred, on the other hand, jokingly pities Scrooge because "he hasn't the satisfaction of thinking—ha, ha, ha!—that he is ever going to" plough over his wealth to Fred. And so maybe Fred is kind to his uncle partly because he hopes to benefit financially.

Meanwhile, in i possible vision of the future, Scrooge's business organization associates mock him just after he dies, with one saying he'll attend the funeral simply "if lunch is provided." Servants rob the just-deceased moneylender's dwelling house of clothes, defunction, blankets, silverware, and more besides.

Scrooge may be rightly criticized for his refusal to requite during "the flavor of giving." Just it should be noted that Scrooge also never asks for anything. This may be even more unusual than his absence of charity, considering as however another defense of Scrooge argued in a Wall Street Periodical op-ed, "Whatever else Christmas is, it's a lot about receiving."

At the end of A Christmas Carol, Scrooge makes some arguably unwise business organization decisions. He impulsively gives Bob Cratchit a heighten, goes on a Christmas Day spending spree, and even writes off clients' debts. Naturally, people liked him a lot more than later. "He became as skillful a friend, as proficient a master, and every bit good a man, as skilful quondam metropolis knew, or any other good old city, town, or borough, in the good old world," Dickens writes.

But let's not forget, even before his dramatic transformation, Scrooge was already quite a good and honorable businessman.